I've taken a leap of faith (based on careful research, of course) in my decision to leave the warm, comfortable, known-quantity of my venerable first generation iPhone. It was a tough choice and one that I agonized over for months. The iPhone has been good to me and I almost feel sad leaving it behind, but I have been experiencing some glitches with it lately that have made me pine for something a bit better.
The Android interface has intrigued me from the outset. I've had occasion to see it on several devices and the only thing that made me hold off trying it before now was that it lacked the spit-and-polish feel of the iPhone. It was like visiting a foreign city - everything you are used to is still there, just in all the wrong places and sometimes you just don't get what you need. Some time has passed since my first look at Android and I'm happy to report that some things improved, but sad to say that not everything is Zen.
I had intended to do a carefully documented un-boxing, side-by-side comparo with the 1st gen iPhone, and step-by-step setup video when I got my Nexus One yesterday, but the excited little boy took over and I ripped off the packaging like it was Christmas morning. After popping in the battery and starting the charging process, I initiated the port of my AT&T number. All told, it took about 6.5 hours to complete the setup and migration over to T-Mobile. As of right now, I am fairly certain that the process is complete, but I still need to figure out how AT&T is going to punish me for my transgressions against them.
So what works?
Well, let's start off with the physical form and feel of the Nexus One. It's a handsome device, which was another leap of faith on my part since there's no way to actually SEE the thing before you buy it. Thankfully, it's quite nice. The outer shell is a rubberized plastic material and the front of it is an oleophobic glass face much like the 3GS. The top of the phone has an unlock button and a 3.5mm headphone jack, but their positions are opposite the iPhone. Volume controls are placed on the left side in pretty much the exact spot as the iPhone, although the up and down rocker is slightly more recessed. The glass front contains a speaker at the top of the screen, and four "soft" buttons for back, menu, home, and search at the bottom. Just below the screen is the scroll ball. It serves the dual purpose of navigation and message notification light similar to late model Blackberry phones. The bottom of the phone has the microphone and a micro USB jack. The outward face of the phone has the camera, the LED flash (more on that here shortly) and a noise-canceling microphone. The overall color scheme is a two-tone graphite style. The look of it is dark and fairly business-like.
The screen itself deserves it's own section - it is stunningly pretty. I was prepared to be only slightly impressed with it, but I have to say that after using it that the 3.7" 480X800 AMOLED screen lives up to the hype. Just thumbing through the phone's OS is nice, but cranking up a video on YouTube and watching at a high resolution is by far better than the iPhone in my opinion.
The interface itself is quite easy to use - after using it for less than 24 hours, I feel at this point as though I have managed to get everything set up like I want it. I like the widgets feature and while incredibly cool, the live wallpapers are going to be good for only one thing: distracting my daughters when I need a couple of minutes of quiet. Otherwise, the animations just chew up processor speed (although not in tangible way). The mail functions are nice and the controls are logical. One thing that I didn't immediately notice was the window shade that pulls down from the top of the screen that contains notifications for mail and text messages - I really like this feature because it offer an at-a-glance view of all inbound communication.
The camera feature is easy to use, but I need to interject one negative here - the flash is way too bright and tends to wash out the picture. The video camera works very well and the integration options to publish the videos and pictures quickly are appreciated features. Less thrilling are the gallery features, but I'll cover this below.
So what do I not like?
Let's get this out of the way now - at the stage I am now with the Nexus One, I feel that text input is pretty awful. I was not happy with the iPhone in this regard and I'm even less happy with the Nexus One. It's very twitchy, resulting in some less-than-desirable events. For example, I was trying to compose a simple email and it took an unnecessarily long time to type in an email address that was not in my contact list. Typing the body was equally annoying and the auto-correct feature reminds me of trying to type on my least favorite device ever made - the Blackberry Pearl. The soft keyboard is completely unusable for me in portrait mode and only marginally better in landscape. Having said all this, I'm not entirely unhappy because there is one saving grace: speech-to-text input. This function is outstanding. With no training whatsoever, I was able to compose a very complex message with only minor corrections for punctuation. I intentionally used words that I thought would throw it off ("palindrome", "endometriosis", "pellicle", and "endoplasmic reticulum") but it worked extremely well. Now I just have to get over the distaste I have for dictating emails in public.
Aside from the text input problem, I should mention that there is no provision for calendar synchronization using ActiveSync. I can get my email this way, but not my corporate calendar. The phone does sync with my Google calendar, so I may need to adjust a bit to compensate. Regardless, this is a big shortcoming and one that I think may scare some folks off. I knew this going in because I researched it, but was willing to accept it because I know there is high demand for it to be fixed and there really are few times when I really need to use my calendar anyway. Hopefully Google will get going on adding the feature.
More "meh": The picture gallery is just weird. I don't like it. It's interesting, but unnecessarily complex. I liked the gallery function on the iPhone for the simplicity. Also, I don't like the fact that there is no option in the camera feature to jump straight into the gallery of photos. These are minor complaints, but definitely worth noting if these things are important to you. Also, I have decided not to move my music to the Nexus One because it would mean a long conversion process that I have no interest in undertaking. I have an iPod for music. I will miss my tech podcasts, but I suppose I could put those on the iPod as well.
So which device do I prefer? Well, I can't really say just yet. I need more time to adjust and become acclimated, but I can definitively say that I am very impressed with Nexus One and I would recommend it wholeheartedly to anyone who has never owned an iPhone.
More to follow as the days progress. I can tell you at this moment that I am fairly certain that I will have another blog post regarding T-Mobile. I'm cautiously optimistic about using them as a provider and I hope that I won't be disappointed. Time will tell.